1. Introduction to Hawaii’s Auto Insurance System

​

Hawaii’s auto insurance laws are unique and can be confusing, especially for people unfamiliar with the state’s no-fault structure. As a Honolulu auto accident injury lawyer, David W. Barlow has spent years guiding injured drivers, passengers, and pedestrians through the intricate network of insurance requirements, deadlines, and claims procedures that make Hawaii’s system one of the most complex in the country. The no-fault system was designed to reduce court congestion and streamline compensation for medical expenses, but it often leaves accident victims unsure of how to recover full damages for pain, suffering, and long-term losses.

 

When you are injured in an auto accident in Hawaii, the first layer of compensation typically comes from your own insurance policy under Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage, regardless of who was at fault. However, the moment your injuries exceed that coverage or meet certain severity thresholds, the process becomes far more complicated. At that point, you may have the right to bring a claim against the negligent driver and pursue full compensation for your pain and suffering, lost wages, and future care. Attorney David W. Barlow, based in Honolulu, ensures that his clients understand when to stay within Hawaii’s no-fault system and when to step outside it to recover the full amount they deserve.

​

2. What “No-Fault” Really Means in Hawaii

​

Many people misunderstand what “no-fault” means in the context of Hawaii auto insurance. It doesn’t mean that fault is ignored, nor does it mean you can’t file a claim against another driver. It simply means that, after most car accidents, each driver first turns to their own insurance company to cover immediate medical expenses and rehabilitation through their PIP benefits. Once those benefits are exhausted or your injuries meet certain qualifying thresholds, you can pursue a traditional liability claim against the driver who caused the crash.

​

For more than a decade, Honolulu injury lawyer David W. Barlow has helped clients navigate this balance between no-fault and fault-based recovery. Many accident victims make the mistake of assuming they have no right to pursue further compensation, leaving thousands of dollars unclaimed. Understanding where the no-fault system ends—and where traditional personal injury law begins—is crucial to maximizing your financial recovery. That’s why working with an attorney familiar with both the insurance and legal sides of Hawaii’s system can make all the difference.

​

3. Personal Injury Protection (PIP) Coverage

​

Under Hawaii law, Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage is mandatory for all registered vehicles. The minimum limit is $10,000, though higher coverage is highly recommended. PIP pays for your medical treatment, prescription medications, hospital visits, physical therapy, and rehabilitation costs, regardless of fault. It ensures that you can begin treatment immediately after a crash without waiting for a liability determination.

​

However, PIP does not pay for everything. It doesn’t cover pain and suffering, emotional distress, or other non-economic damages. Once your medical bills exceed your PIP limit—or if your injuries meet the tort threshold—you can file a claim against the at-fault driver’s insurance. David W. Barlow, an experienced Honolulu car accident attorney, carefully reviews each client’s insurance policy to confirm coverage levels, coordinate payments, and preserve the client’s right to future recovery. His office helps ensure that PIP benefits are used correctly, medical bills are processed efficiently, and no insurance company denies legitimate claims.

​

4. When You Can File a Claim Against the At-Fault Driver

​

Hawaii’s tort threshold determines when you can file a lawsuit or third-party claim against a negligent driver. This threshold is met if you have incurred more than $5,000 in medical expenses or if you have suffered significant injuries such as permanent loss of use of a body part, disfigurement, or death. Once you meet that standard, you can pursue damages beyond what your PIP coverage provides.

​

At this stage, having a lawyer like David W. Barlow becomes essential. Insurance companies will often dispute whether your injuries meet the legal threshold, and they may use technicalities to delay or deny your claim. David works with medical experts, economists, and investigators to prove the true extent of your injuries and establish that your case qualifies for full compensation. By acting quickly and building strong medical documentation, his team ensures that you are not trapped in the limited no-fault system when your injuries clearly justify a full tort claim.

​

5. Understanding Liability and Bodily Injury Coverage

​

Hawaii requires all drivers to carry Bodily Injury Liability (BIL) coverage of at least $20,000 per person and $40,000 per accident. This coverage protects others if the insured driver causes an accident. For victims, it represents the first major opportunity to recover money beyond PIP. However, navigating BIL claims can be challenging, especially when multiple parties are involved or when insurance companies try to minimize payouts.

​

David W. Barlow, a Honolulu personal injury lawyer, has extensive experience dealing with liability insurers in Hawaii. He investigates the full scope of available coverage, identifies all responsible parties, and ensures that claims are filed correctly and on time. In many cases, there are multiple layers of coverage—such as employer policies, commercial policies, or excess insurance—that can significantly increase the total recovery. By exploring every avenue, Attorney Barlow helps clients obtain the maximum compensation available under Hawaii’s auto insurance laws.

​

6. Uninsured and Underinsured Motorist Coverage (UM/UIM)

​

Unfortunately, not every driver on Hawaii’s roads follows the law. Some drive without insurance or with policies that barely meet the minimum legal limits. Uninsured Motorist (UM) and Underinsured Motorist (UIM) coverage protect you in those situations. If the at-fault driver has no insurance or insufficient coverage, your own UM/UIM policy steps in to cover the difference.

​

Many drivers do not realize that UM/UIM coverage is optional, and too often, they decline it to save a few dollars—only to discover later that it could have saved them thousands. Honolulu accident lawyer David W. Barlow advises every Hawaii driver to carry generous UM/UIM limits. For clients who already have this coverage, he ensures that claims are filed properly and that insurance companies do not wrongfully deny or undervalue legitimate UM/UIM benefits. His deep understanding of policy language and case law allows him to fight back when insurers attempt to avoid paying what they owe.

​

7. Property Damage Coverage

​

Auto accidents in Hawaii can result not only in personal injury but also in significant property damage. State law requires every driver to carry at least $10,000 in Property Damage Liability (PDL) coverage to pay for the other driver’s vehicle if they are at fault. Many drivers also purchase Comprehensive and Collision coverage to protect their own vehicles.

​

Property damage claims may seem straightforward, but disputes often arise over repair costs, total-loss valuations, or diminished value claims. David W. Barlow assists clients in negotiating fair settlements for their vehicles while simultaneously managing their injury claims. His office coordinates communications with repair shops, insurance adjusters, and lienholders to ensure that every aspect of the case is handled correctly. In many situations, a well-managed property claim helps strengthen the overall personal injury case by establishing fault and documenting the severity of the collision.

​

8. The Role of Health Insurance in Auto Accident Claims

​

After a serious accident, your health insurance may step in once your PIP benefits are exhausted. In Hawaii, providers such as HMSA, Kaiser, and HMAA often pay additional medical bills under their health plans. However, most of these companies include reimbursement clauses that require you to repay them if you later receive a settlement or judgment.

​

These health insurance liens can dramatically reduce your net recovery if not handled properly. Attorney David W. Barlow negotiates with health insurers and medical lienholders to reduce or waive these reimbursement demands whenever possible. His knowledge of Hawaii’s insurance subrogation laws ensures that clients keep more of their settlement funds. Coordinating between auto insurance, health insurance, and medical providers requires experience and attention to detail—two things his Honolulu office provides every day.

​

9. Coordination Between Multiple Insurance Policies

​

A single Hawaii auto accident may trigger multiple overlapping insurance policies—PIP, health, UM/UIM, and even employer or disability coverage. Knowing which policy to use first and how to preserve future claims can significantly affect your outcome. David W. Barlow takes a hands-on approach, analyzing every client’s insurance situation and advising on the best order to file claims.

​

Improperly sequencing insurance payments can cause delays, denials, or even loss of benefits. For example, submitting bills to health insurance before exhausting PIP could violate policy terms. Likewise, signing releases too early can unintentionally waive UM/UIM rights. With his experience as a Honolulu personal injury attorney, Barlow ensures that all claims are coordinated efficiently, deadlines are met, and insurance companies cannot exploit technical loopholes to deny payment.

​

10. Common Insurance Company Tactics

​

Insurance companies often present themselves as friendly and helpful, but their true goal is to minimize payouts. Adjusters may downplay your injuries, delay communication, or argue that your pain is unrelated to the crash. Some offer lowball settlements within days of the accident, hoping you’ll sign before realizing the full extent of your injuries.

​

David W. Barlow, a trusted Honolulu auto accident lawyer, recognizes these tactics and knows how to counter them. He handles all communications with insurers, gathers evidence to prove damages, and negotiates firmly for fair compensation. His reputation for thorough case preparation often leads to faster, higher settlements because insurers know he’s willing to take cases to court if necessary. By letting an experienced attorney handle negotiations, clients avoid costly mistakes that could jeopardize their claims.

​

11. The Importance of Documentation

​

Proper documentation can make or break an insurance claim. Keeping a detailed record of medical visits, receipts, correspondence, and photos of the accident scene helps prove the scope of your damages. Attorney Barlow encourages every client to maintain an accident journal documenting daily pain levels, physical limitations, and emotional struggles.

​

These records serve as powerful evidence when negotiating with insurance adjusters or presenting your case in arbitration or trial. In addition, Barlow’s Honolulu law office compiles and organizes medical records, witness statements, and employment records to support wage-loss claims. The stronger the documentation, the harder it becomes for an insurance company to dispute your injuries or reduce your payout. This disciplined approach consistently results in more successful outcomes for clients.

​

12. What to Do if the Insurance Company Denies Your Claim

​

Even legitimate claims are sometimes denied. Insurers may claim that your injuries are preexisting, that treatment was unnecessary, or that you missed filing deadlines. A denial letter can be discouraging, but it’s not the end of the road. David W. Barlow helps clients challenge denials by gathering additional evidence, requesting reconsideration, or filing formal appeals.

​

If negotiations fail, his firm is ready to file a lawsuit to enforce your rights under Hawaii’s insurance laws. Many cases settle once insurers realize they cannot rely on weak technicalities. With experience in both negotiation and litigation, Barlow ensures that no valid claim goes unpaid. His persistence and attention to legal detail often turn denials into successful recoveries for his Honolulu clients.

​

13. How Fault Affects Your Compensation

​

Hawaii follows a modified comparative negligence system, meaning that your compensation is reduced by your percentage of fault, so long as you are less than 51% responsible. If you are 25% at fault and awarded $100,000, you would receive $75,000. Determining fault accurately is therefore critical.

​

Insurance adjusters often try to exaggerate your share of responsibility to reduce payouts. Attorney David W. Barlow investigates each accident thoroughly, working with experts in accident reconstruction and witness analysis to challenge these unfair assessments. By presenting strong evidence and clear causation, he protects his clients from unjust blame and ensures that their recovery reflects the true circumstances of the accident.

​

14. The Settlement Process

​

The settlement process in Hawaii involves gathering all medical records, bills, and supporting evidence into a comprehensive demand package. This package is presented to the insurance company with a detailed explanation of injuries, treatment, pain, and financial losses. Barlow’s experience allows him to craft persuasive demand letters that command attention and respect from insurance adjusters.

​

Negotiations often follow over several weeks or months. Throughout the process, Barlow keeps clients informed and involved, ensuring they understand each offer and counteroffer. If the insurer refuses to be reasonable, his office prepares to file a lawsuit and move forward with litigation. This combination of strategic patience and readiness to act yields the best results for injury victims across Honolulu and the islands.

​

15. Arbitration and Mediation in Hawaii Injury Claims

​

Hawaii’s court system requires most personal injury cases to go through Court-Annexed Arbitration before trial. Arbitration provides a faster, less formal resolution process, while mediation offers a chance for both sides to reach an agreement voluntarily. Attorney David W. Barlow has extensive experience in both arenas, presenting cases clearly and persuasively before arbitrators and mediators.

​

His approach focuses on preparation and evidence—key factors that often determine the outcome. Many of his clients’ cases settle favorably during these proceedings, saving them the time and stress of a full trial. Because Barlow has participated in Hawaii’s arbitration program for years, he understands how local arbitrators evaluate cases and what evidence they find most compelling.

​

16. How Long You Have to File a Claim

​

Hawaii law imposes a strict two-year statute of limitations for most personal injury and property damage claims. Missing that deadline can permanently bar your recovery, regardless of how strong your case might be. The clock usually starts on the date of the accident, but certain exceptions exist, such as delayed discovery of injury.

​

David W. Barlow ensures that every claim is filed on time and that clients do not lose their rights due to administrative mistakes. He also helps clients preserve evidence and documentation immediately after an accident, which becomes critical as time passes. Even if you are still receiving medical treatment, consulting a lawyer early allows you to secure your rights and avoid costly delays.

​

17. Tips for Dealing with Insurance Adjusters

​

Insurance adjusters are trained to protect their company’s bottom line, not yours. They may seem friendly but are skilled at asking leading questions that could harm your case. Attorney Barlow advises clients never to provide recorded statements or sign medical authorizations without legal counsel.

​

He personally handles adjuster communications, ensuring all statements are accurate and complete. This approach protects clients from manipulation and prevents insurers from twisting their words later. By letting an experienced Honolulu auto accident attorney deal with adjusters, clients stay focused on healing while their lawyer safeguards the value of their claim.

​

18. Common Myths About Auto Insurance Claims

​

There are many misconceptions about Hawaii’s insurance system. Some drivers believe they cannot sue after an accident because Hawaii is “no-fault.” Others fear that hiring a lawyer will cost more than it’s worth or that their premiums will skyrocket if they file a claim. These myths often lead to costly mistakes.

​

In reality, most personal injury attorneys—including David W. Barlow—work on a contingency fee, meaning you pay nothing unless you win. Filing a valid claim for compensation typically does not affect your insurance rates, especially if you were not at fault. Educating clients about these truths is a core part of Barlow’s mission as a Honolulu personal injury lawyer. Knowledge empowers accident victims to make informed decisions that protect their rights and financial futures.

​

19. Why You Need an Experienced Honolulu Auto Accident Lawyer

​

Navigating Hawaii’s complicated web of PIP, liability, UM/UIM, and health insurance coverage without professional help can quickly become overwhelming. Every step—from submitting bills to negotiating settlements—affects your final outcome. David W. Barlow provides clear, practical guidance and handles every detail of your case so you can focus on recovery.

​

As a seasoned Honolulu auto accident injury lawyer, he combines local insight, legal expertise, and personal attention to deliver outstanding results. His clients value his responsiveness, honesty, and willingness to fight for what’s fair. When insurance companies know they’re up against a lawyer with a record of success, they’re far more likely to settle for full value rather than risk losing in court.

​

20. Contact the Law Offices of David W. Barlow

​

If you or a loved one has been injured in an auto accident anywhere in Honolulu or across Hawaii, contact the Law Offices of David W. Barlow today for a free consultation. David will personally review your insurance coverage, explain your rights, and create a strategy to maximize your recovery.

​

Don’t face the insurance companies alone. Let an experienced Hawaii personal injury lawyer protect your rights and secure the full compensation you deserve.