Hawaii Auto Accident Statistics: What We Learned From More Than 100 Hawaii Injury Cases In The Past 5 Years

​

If you have been injured in a car accident in Hawaii, you may be wondering how your case compares to other accidents that happen across the islands. Over the past five years, the Law Offices of David W. Barlow has handled more than 100 Hawaii auto accident injury cases involving cars, motorcycles, mopeds, bicycles, pedestrians, e-bikes, and scooters. While every case is different, reviewing the data from these cases provides some interesting insights into how accidents occur, which insurance companies are most commonly involved, and what types of crashes lead to injury claims.

​

As a Hawaii auto accident injury lawyer, I spend a significant amount of time helping injured people navigate Hawaii's insurance system. Looking back at the data from these cases gives us a better understanding of the accident patterns we see most often throughout Honolulu, Oahu, Maui, Kauai, and the Big Island.

​

The Most Common Type of Hawaii Auto Accident

​

One of the clearest trends in our data is that rear-end collisions are by far the most common type of accident.

​

Accident Types From Our Cases

​​

Rear-End Collisions: 51 (45.5%)

Failure to Yield: 33 (29.5%)

Negligence: 11 (9.8%)

Ran Stop Sign/Light: 10 (8.9%)

Distracted Driving: 5  (4.5%)

Speeding: 2 (1.8%)

Fell Asleep: 1 (.9%)

​

Rear-end collisions accounted for more than 40% of all cases. This result is not surprising. Hawaii traffic congestion, especially on Oahu, creates constant stop-and-go traffic. Whether it is the H-1 Freeway, H-2, H-3, Nimitz Highway, Farrington Highway, or Kamehameha Highway, drivers frequently follow too closely or fail to react quickly enough when traffic slows.

​

Many people mistakenly believe rear-end accidents only cause minor injuries. In reality, some of the most serious neck injuries, back injuries, and disc injuries we see come from rear-end crashes.

The second most common cause was failure-to-yield accidents. These crashes often occur at intersections when drivers turn left across traffic, fail to yield while entering roadways, or pull into traffic without sufficient space.

​

What Types of Vehicles Were Involved?

​

Many people think Hawaii auto accident injury lawyers only handle car accidents. The reality is that serious injuries occur in many different types of vehicle accidents.

​

Vehicle Types

​​

Auto (car, truck, bus, etc.): 79 (69.3%)

Bicycle: 10 (8.8%)

Pedestrian: 8 (7.0%)

Moped: 8 (7.0%)

Motorcycle: 6 (5.3%)

E-Scooter: 2  (1.8%)

E-Bike: 1 (0.9%)

​​​

Cars accounted for nearly 70% of all injury cases. However, nearly one-third of the cases involved vulnerable road users such as bicyclists, pedestrians, motorcyclists, and moped riders.

​

This is important because these cases often involve more serious injuries. Unlike drivers inside vehicles, pedestrians and riders have very little protection during a collision.

​

Why Pedestrian Accidents Are So Serious

​

Hawaii pedestrian accidents represented approximately 7% of our cases. That may not sound like a large number, but these cases often involve some of the most severe injuries.

​

A pedestrian struck by a vehicle may suffer:

• Broken bones

• Head injuries

• Traumatic brain injuries

• Spinal injuries

• Internal injuries

• Permanent disabilities

​

Honolulu consistently ranks among the more dangerous areas for pedestrians because of heavy traffic, tourism, and high pedestrian activity throughout Waikiki, Ala Moana, Downtown Honolulu, and other busy areas.

​

Moped Accidents Continue To Be A Problem

​

Moped accidents in Hawaii accounted for roughly 7% of our cases.

​

Mopeds remain extremely popular throughout Honolulu and Oahu because they are relatively inexpensive and convenient. Unfortunately, riders are exposed during collisions and often suffer significant injuries.

​

One unique aspect of Hawaii law is that mopeds are treated differently from motorcycles for insurance purposes. Many injured riders are surprised to learn how Hawaii's no-fault insurance system applies to moped accidents.

​

Motorcycle Accident Injuries Are Often Severe

​

Motorcycle accidents in Hawaii represented about 5% of our cases.

​

Although motorcycles make up a relatively small percentage of claims, these accidents often involve substantial injuries due to the lack of physical protection.

​

Common motorcycle accident injuries include:

​

• Fractures

• Road rash

• Head injuries

• Shoulder injuries

• Knee injuries

• Spinal injuries

​

Insurance companies frequently fight these cases aggressively because the damages can be significant.

​

Which Insurance Companies Appear Most Often?

​

The data also revealed interesting trends regarding insurance companies involved in Hawaii injury claims.

​

Most Common Bodily Injury Insurance Companies

​

Geico: 28 (24.6%)

State Farm: 17 (14.9%)

Allstate: 12 (10.5%)

USAA: 11 (9.6%)

Farmers: 9 (7.9%)

Progressive: 9 (7.9%)

Island Insurance: 5 (4.4%)

None: 5 (4.4%)

First Insurance: 4 (3.5%)

AAA: 2 (1.8%)

Dongbu/Atlas: 2 (1.8%)

DTRIC: 2 (1.8%)

ESIS: 2 (1.8%)

Travelers: 2 (1.8%)

Gallagher: 1 (0.9%)

Liberty Mutual: 1 (0.9%)

National: 1 (0.9%)

Sedgwick: 1 (0.9%)

​

Geico appeared most frequently among the bodily injury carriers in our data.

​

This does not necessarily mean Geico drivers cause more accidents. It may simply reflect market share.

However, it does show that many Hawaii injury claims involve large national insurance companies.

​

Most Common No-Fault Insurance Companies (PIP: Personal Injury Protection)

​

Geico: 36 (34.3%)

State Farm: 15 (14.3%)

Progressive: 12 (11.4%)

USAA: 11 (10.5%)

Farmers: 8 (7.6%)

First Insurance: 7 (6.7%)

Allstate: 3 (2.9%)

Sedgwick: 3 (2.9%)

DTRIC: 2 (1.9%)

ESIS: 2 (1.9%)

Island Insurance: 2 (1.9%)

AAA: 1 (1.0%)

Alliance of NonProfits: 1 (1.0%)

Crawford & Co.: 1 (1.0%)

Dongbu/Atlas: 1 (1.0%)

​

Geico also appeared most frequently as the no-fault insurance carrier.

​

Because Hawaii follows a no-fault system, every accident claim begins with PIP benefits. Understanding how these benefits work is one of the most important parts of any Hawaii auto accident injury claim.

​

What This Means For Hawaii Drivers

​

Several lessons can be learned from this data.

​

Lesson #1: Rear-End Accidents Are Extremely Common

​

More than four out of every ten cases involved rear-end collisions.

​

Drivers should maintain safe following distances and avoid distractions while driving.

​

Lesson #2: Intersections Are Dangerous

​

Nearly one-third of the cases involved failure-to-yield accidents.

​

Many serious injuries occur when drivers turn left across traffic or fail to properly yield at intersections.

​

Lesson #3: Vulnerable Road Users Face Higher Risks

​

Bicyclists, pedestrians, motorcyclists, and moped riders represented nearly one-third of all non-auto cases.

​

These accidents often involve more severe injuries and larger claims.

​

Lesson #4: Insurance Companies Are Involved In Every Stage

​

Whether the Hawaii insurance company is Geico, State Farm, Allstate, Farmers, Progressive, USAA, or another carrier, every case ultimately involves dealing with insurance adjusters and claim representatives.

Understanding how insurance companies evaluate claims can make a significant difference in the outcome of a case.

​

Why These Statistics Matter

​

Many people assume their accident is unique. While every injury and every client is different, accident patterns tend to repeat themselves.

The same mistakes happen over and over:

​

• Following too closely

• Failing to yield

• Running red lights

• Distracted driving

• Speeding

​

Understanding these trends helps injured victims understand how their accidents occurred and why liability is often clearer than insurance companies would like them to believe.

​

The Importance of Early Legal Representation

​

One thing the statistics do not show is how much easier a claim becomes when an attorney is involved early in the process.

​

Insurance companies begin investigating immediately after a crash.

​

Evidence disappears.

​

Witnesses become difficult to locate.

​

Memories fade.

​

Medical records become harder to organize.

​

The sooner an injured person consults a Hawaii auto accident injury lawyer, the easier it is to preserve evidence and protect their rights.

​

Final Thoughts

​

After reviewing more than 100 Hawaii auto accident injury cases from the past five years, several patterns stand out. Rear-end collisions remain the most common accident type. Failure-to-yield crashes continue to cause a large percentage of injuries. Pedestrian, bicycle, motorcycle, and moped accidents frequently result in serious injuries. Large insurance companies such as Geico, State Farm, Allstate, USAA, and Farmers appear repeatedly throughout Hawaii injury claims.

​

While statistics can be helpful, every accident case is unique. The value of a claim depends on the specific injuries, medical treatment, wage loss, insurance coverage, and many other factors.

​

If you have been injured in a car accident, pedestrian accident, bicycle accident, motorcycle crash, or moped collision anywhere in Hawaii, it is important to understand your rights before speaking extensively with insurance companies. An experienced Hawaii auto accident injury lawyer can help you navigate Hawaii's no-fault insurance system, protect your claim, and pursue the compensation you deserve.

​

David W. Barlow is a Hawaii Auto Accident Injury Lawyer representing injured clients throughout Honolulu, Oahu, Maui, Kauai, and the Big Island.